All

Alt Exhibition Spaces

Research: Alternative Exhibition Spaces

“Why only look at exhibition history as evidence of an artist showing their work? Instead, I suggest we broaden this idea of showing work to sharing work.”
Vera Molnar, Ni Queue ni Tête (Neither Tail nor Head) (2014), 15 x 15 cm (folded)

A collaborative project bringing together a visual work by Molnar, a composition and text by Jean-Yves Bosseur, and performance by Pascal Dubreuil. Edited and published by Couleurs Contemporaines and Bernard Chauveau. The work is housed in a custom-made portfolio box containing Molnar’s six meter long folded artwork, printed on 90-gram Acroprint Edizioni paper; a musical score partition booklet by Bosseur; and a CD of Dubreuil’s performance.
“Enter the alternative spaces in which Molnar’s work reached audiences: informal research groups, festivals, academic journals and conferences, art magazines, and self-published artist’s books.”
Vera Molnar,
Ni Queue ni tête
(mouse over)

The usual narrative around Vera Molnar’s work is that she didn’t exhibit her work until the mid-1970s, and even then, only sparingly. It is true that she didn’t focus on exhibiting and building relationships with galleries until the 1990s, especially after her husband passed away. Whether her husband was the reason why she didn’t exhibit much before this is up for debate, but let’s save that for another day. Instead, I want to ask a different question: why only look at exhibition history as evidence of an artist showing their work? In today’s research note, I suggest we broaden this idea of showing work to sharing work. In other words, what were the more informal contexts in which Molnar shared her images or her ideas? We are going to peek at some of the alternative spaces in which Molnar’s work reached audiences: informal research groups, festivals, academic journals and conferences, art magazines, and self-published artist’s books.

In 1967, a year before she first accessed the electronic computer with the help of Pierre Barbaud, the Molnars co-founded the group Art et informatique (Art and computing) at l’Institut d’esthétique et des sciences de l’art (Institute for aesthetics and the science of art) at the Sorbonne in Paris, where François Molnar worked as a researcher. The group mainly consisted of music composers, including Barbaud and Janine Charbonnier, but also included poets like Jacques Mayer, who wrote in the parameter-driven Oulipo style made famous by novelist George Perec. Vera Molnar was the only painter in the group; in fact, despite their near-identical names, Art et Informatique would have little contact with the Groupe Art et Informatique de Vincennes (GAIV), formed at the University of Vincennes across town in 1969. As Molnar recalls, the Sorbonne group met weekly to discuss their works-in-progress and the more theoretical stakes of computing for the field of aesthetics. As these conversations gained momentum, the members of Art et informatique shared their work with broader audiences at events like the SIGMA festival in Bordeaux, which showcased contemporary intersections of art and science. While François Molnar had already participated in the first edition of SIGMA in 1965, co-organized by Michel Philippot (the composer who inspired Vera Molnar’s ‘machine imaginaire’) and Abraham Moles (who developed the field of ‘information aesthetics’ in France), Vera Molnar did not formally participate in the festival until 1973, when the festival was titled “Art et ordinateur” (Art and computer). Here, she gave a talk titled “L’Oeil qui pense (The thinking eye),” which she borrowed from the notebooks of Paul Klee. She also designed the festival posters as well as the catalogue for the exhibition “Contact,” in which her computer plotter drawings were shown alongside computer graphics made by Herbert W. Franke, Kenneth Knowlton, Manfred Mohr, Frieder Nake, and the GAIV artists, among many others.

“In response to her 1975 Leonardo text ‘Toward Aesthetic Guidelines for Paintings with the Aid of a Computer,’ Molnar received quite a bit of fan mail. She replied by mailing out photocopies of her artists’ books.”
Vera Molnar (left) and François Molnar (right) with Jacques Chaban-Delmas, then mayor of Bordeaux, at the first SIGMA festival in Bordeaux, 1965 (Molnar archives, used with permission of Vera Molnar)
(1) Vera Molnar, Cover for Computer Graphics and Art, Vol. 2, No. 1 (Feb 1977; Molnar archives)

(2) Vera Molnar’s article in Leonardo, Vol. 8, No. 3 (1975: 185-189) (Molnar archives)

(3) Vera Molnar’s work reproduced in Abraham Moles’ book Art et ordinateur (Casterman, 1971), likely the earliest circulation of Molnar’s images in print. Note that the image reproduced (left) is not a plotter drawing, but a collage based on a computer-generated image.
Vera Molnar’s artist book Ni Queue ni Tête (Neither Tail nor Head) (2014) on view at Beall Center (table)
Conferences, journals,
artists’ books
(mouse over)

It was in these liminal spaces between art and science that Vera Molnar’s work first reached an international audience beyond the Sorbonne computer lab. Throughout the 1970s, her images circulated in American periodicals including Computers and Automation, (later renamed Computers and People) and Computer Graphics. These black-and-white reproductions were flanked by technical specs––what machines she used to make them––as well as short anecdotes from the artist. Molnar also penned longer articles for journals, perhaps the most widely distributed being the Franco-American journal Leonardo, edited by artist/engineer Frank Malina, which was published in English and thus had a wide Anglo-American readership. In response to her 1975 text “Toward Aesthetic Guidelines for Paintings with the Aid of a Computer,” Molnar received quite a bit of fan mail. She replied by mailing out photocopies of her livrimages, her artists’ books, including Love-Story and Out of Square (both 1974), which she referred to in English as “computer picture books,” until she ran out. Molnar self-published her early livrimages, cutting and pasting their accordion folds by hand, only later collaborating with printmakers and publishers (mostly notably Bernard Chauveau) to make higher-quality artist’s books, two of which are included in the Beall exhibition (Ni Queue ni tête, 2014 and Six millions sept cent soixante-cinq mille deux cent une Sainte-Victoire, 2012).

“Alternative modes of ‘exhibiting’ might have done things for Molnar that showing in traditional art venues couldn’t have: they brought her work to an international, more open-minded audience.”

I don’t mean to suggest that giving an artist’s talk at an academic conference, or publishing computer graphics in a specialist journal, are the same as gaining art-world recognition. Of course, these are quite different kinds of achievements. However, I want to suggest that these alternative modes of ‘exhibiting’ might have done things for Molnar’s work that exhibiting in traditional art venues couldn’t have. For one, they brought her work to an international audience, one that was perhaps more open-minded than the traditional museum-goer when it came to determining what counts as art and what doesn’t. Moreover, by printing her words alongside reproductions of her work, these print publications in particular worked to level the hierarchy between the artist’s theory and practice, placing them on equal footing. On the one hand, we could say Molnar had to be her own critic in the absence of art-world attention. But on the other hand, this gave her an advantage, as these venues provided more space for context and the artist’s own voice, allowing her to direct her own narrative.

(1) For more on Molnar’s Livrimages, see Vincent Baby’s text “Les Livrimages” (1999, in French)

Inspired by Mycology and Web3 the 2022 ARKO Art & Tech Festival Chronicles “The Fable of Net in Earth”

“The Fable of Net in Earth,” the 2022 ARKO Art & Tech Festival kicks off in Seoul. Inspired by decentralization (mycology, Web3), it brings together Morehshin Allahyari, SunJeong Hwang, and Young Joo Lee, and others. Featured works include Eobchaecoin (2022), Nahee Kim’s unabashedly ponzi cryptocurrency (it will be very profitable in 2082), and De Anima (2018-21, image), Clara Jo’s film probing humanity’s relationship with nature, that draws on footage from Kenya, Myanmar, and France.

Amazon Further Normalizes Surveillance With New TV Show

“Using fear-mongering about package theft and suburban crime, a surveillance company has convinced countless homes to affix a surveillance network node. Now they want us to laugh about it all in our (ideally) Ring-surveilled homes.“
Motherboard staff writer Edward Ongweso Jr, on the upcoming launch of Ring Nation, Amazon’s new tv show featuring videos taken from Amazon Ring surveillance cameras

Harm Van Den Dorpel Releases Desktop NFT Viewer for Greater Decentralization

Dutch crypto artist Harm van den Dorpel releases the Mutant Garden Seeder desktop app to the general public. The software, previously exclusive to holders of his well-known NFT project, helps “aid the greater plan of decentralisation,” the website states. “This ‘read-only sidechain’ synchronises to Ethereum Mainnet, and lets your mutants live and grow on your own local computer.” Released in 2021, Mutant Garden Seeder comprises 512 generative unique Ethereum NFTs that evolve over time.

Only Averages: Kevin Buist Parses the Rise of AI-Generated Imagery

“When we look at AI images, we’re unable to match our subjectivity as viewers with the artist’s subjectivity as a creator. Instead of a particular human experience, we’re shown only averages.”
– Design strategist, curator, and writer Kevin Buist, parsing the deluge of digital art created with AI image generators like DALL-E. “AI is not exactly copying artists,” writes Buist. “It’s using their images to generalize visual depictions of everything language can express.”

A Meta-Documentary About the Looping Labour of NPCs Wins Best Direction at Locarno Film Festival

An ethnographic exploration of the work and daily life of non-playable characters, Total Refusal’s meta-documentary Hardly Working premieres (and wins best direction) at Locarno Film Festival, Switzerland. The film follows four digital extras—a laundress, a stableman, a street sweeper, a handyman—toiling away in the videogame Red Dead Redemption 2 (2018). “Their labour loops, activity patterns as well as bugs and malfunctions paint a vivid analogy for work under capitalism.”

Ohan Breiding Gushes about How Astrida Neimanis’ “Bodies of Water” Has Influenced Their Work

“Bodies are made up of this substance, which existed before bodies existed. Your water is the same as mine inside, but we’re very different people. Skin both links us to the outside world and separates us from it.”
– Artist Ohan Breiding, explaining the ‘hydrocommons.’ Part of a feature where artists recommend key texts that have influenced their work, Breiding heartily plugs Astrida Neimanis’ Bodies of Water: Posthuman Feminist Phenomenology (2019).

James Bridle Invokes “More-than-Human” as a “Mega-Category” that Includes Everything

“In this framing, no one viewpoint is favored over another, not even the biological over the mineral or mechanical.”
– Writer and In Search of Mycotopia (2021) author Doug Bierend, on James Bridle invoking the “more-than-human” as a “mega-category” in their new book Ways of Being. “It is a grouping so vast,” Bierend writes, “the category disappears, and the interactions within it are what matters.”

This Sweltering Summer UPS Opts for In-Truck Surveillance over Air Conditioning

American logistics company UPS begins installing in-truck surveillance cameras. This summer drivers are reporting back-of-truck cargo area temperatures of 49° C, and in a move that made workers bristle, UPS rolled out Lytx telemetry cameras (image), which track GPS and monitor for “behaviours associated with collisions”—not air conditioning. “Whatever its capabilities, the mere presence of the camera has stoked fear and paranoia among my coworkers,” writes driver Matt Leichenger.

Demosceners Exploit Vintage Teletext Standard for Real-Time Animation

Pushing the vintage tv text and graphics standard into overdrive, 420 Years of Teletext is released at the Evoke demoparty in Cologne. Coder Losso managed to software-generate a teletext signal from a Raspberry Pi that, hooked up to an old-fashioned CRT television set, uses hardware exploits for nifty frame-buffering tricks (more on GitHub). The result: a zany teletext origin story featuring smooth animations, pixel graphics, demoscene in-jokes, and a rocking chiptune track.

Value Does Not Come from Art Being Critical But Articulate, Elliot Woods Says

“If we look back to the beginnings of cinema, then perhaps Man With a Movie Camera might stack up as a strong critical reflection on the medium itself, but we wouldn’t ignore Metropolis and Battleship Potemkin.”
– Elliot Woods of the Seoul-based light art studio Kimchi and Chips, on the merit of different kinds of (AI) art. “Value does not come from a work being critical, but instead from being ‘articulate,’ i.e. capable of processing and producing meaning,” writes Woods.

Risk of Collapse due to Catastrophic Climate Change Underexplored, Scientists Say

“I do not believe civilization as we know it will make it out of this century. Resilient humans will survive, but our societies that have urbanized and are supported by rural agriculture will not.”
– Canadian climate scientist and legislator Andrew Weaver, on the underexplored risks of catastrophic climate change that eleven scientists are warning about in a new Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences paper

Simon Denny and Karamia Müller Tell Euro-Pacific “Creation Stories” about Commerce, Sovereignty, Technology, and Polity

A collaboration between New Zealanders Simon Denny and Karamia Müller, “Creation Stories” opens across two Auckland galleries, Gus Fisher and Michael Lett. In their titular co-creations—a series of circuitboard-like murals—the two map how their family trees but also commerce, sovereignty, technology, and polity connect the Pacific to German-speaking Europe. Also in view: topical works by a dozen other artists including Sarah Friend, Ryan Kuo, and Stella Brennan.

“Patricia Piccinini: We Are Connected” Morphs Contemporary Biopolitics at ArtScience Museum

A retrospective collecting 40 works by the Australian artist, “Patricia Piccinini: We Are Connected” opens at Singapore’s ArtScience Museum. Showcasing her unsettling sculptures and installations that morph contemporary biopolitics towards the grotesque, the show features works including The Bond (2016, image centre) and The Field (2018, image), which, respectively, depict a mother cradling a human-ish fleshy creature, and a (wildly) genetically modified crop.

Cybercrime Journalist Geoff White: ‘North Korea Grooms Next Generation of Hackers’

“From an early age they are trying to spot mathematically talented kids in school. They groom those kids—put them in computer classes—and when those kids show promise they get sent to elite universities.”
– Cybercrime journalist Geoff White, on the state-managed recruiting pipeline for Lazarus Group, the elite North Korean hacker squad. “From there [elite universities] the really gifted computer kids will either go into the nuclear research program … or computer hacking.”

Rhea Myers Rendered Certificates of Inauthenticity for 3D-Printed Canonical Readymades

“I grabbed an old Sol LeWitt certificate of authenticity, got some Wite-Out, whited out the details of his work and just quickly wrote in the details of mine and photocopied it a few times.”
– Blockchain artist Rhea Myers, on the origins of Certificate of Inauthenticity (2020). From 2011 to 2012, Myers commissioned 3D-printed Shareable Readymades from art history’s canon and rendered “sarcastic certificates” upon the exhibiting gallery’s request. “I don’t own the copyright in the works,” Myers notes, “that’s part of the concept of the project.”

Cancelled Toronto Subway Artwork Remains in Limbo, Artists Ghosted

Canadian curator Andrew Lochhead revisits the controversy around realities:united’ cancelled public artwork LightSpell (2017), installed at Toronto’s Pioneer Village subway station. The architectural light matrix was designed for visitor messages but never activated over fears of abuse. “We were commissioned to modify the installation’s software,” the artists reveal in the comments about extensive reworks, “but the Toronto Transit Commission stopped replying to us for unknown reasons.”

$40 USD