Exhibitions, Research, Criticism, Commentary

A chronology of 3,585 references across art, science, technology, and culture
“Being better at making decisions is not the same as making better decisions. To what end are the decisions made by large language models directed? The unsettling truth is that we have no idea.”
– Computer scientist and International Association for Safe and Ethical AI (IASEAI) co-founder Stuart Russell, toasting the second annual TIME100 AI Impact Dinner with a stern warning. “We need to recognize the possibility that not only may the bus of humanity be headed towards a cliff, but the steering wheel is missing, and the driver is blindfolded,” Russell urges.
“Microsoft’s conduct should serve as a wake-up call to other companies supplying cloud infrastructure, AI, and surveillance products to Israel.”
– Amnesty International researcher Matt Mahmoudi, on Microsoft disabling cloud services to Israel’s Defense Ministry after finding the country used its platforms for mass surveillance of Palestinians. The review uncovered cloud storage holding records of millions of daily phone calls—making Microsoft the first major tech firm to act since Israel escalated its military campaign in Gaza following the October 7 attacks in 2023.
“Hot and arid regions like the Gulf are vulnerable. Water demand from AI could become a huge issue by 2027—AI data centres may use more water than entire countries like Denmark, and more energy than countries like France.”
– Technology analyst George Chanos, outlining the scale of resource consumption driving Gulf region AI infrastructure. Despite extreme water scarcity, Gulf states are doubling down on data centres including the UAE’s 1-gigawatt Stargate campus and Saudi Arabia’s 2,200 megawatts of planned capacity.
“Over the last 10 years, we’ve seen a thousand ‘x’ increase in computational speed. Another thousand ‘x’ is projected in the next five years. Things will be very different when we do this in 2030.”
– Christie’s Ventures lead Devang Thakkar, striking an accelerationist tone in introducing the 10th Christie’s Art + Tech Summit. The two-day NYC gathering featured filmmaker Darren Aronofsky, digital artist Refik Anadol, Signal president Meredith Whittaker, and representatives from Apple, Microsoft, and Nvidia. [quote edited]

As protests against ICE raids engulf Los Angeles, software artist Kyle McDonald reactivates his ICEspy (2018) counter surveillance tool. The web app that reveals the identity of ICE employees by matching hundreds of scraped LinkedIn profiles was disabled in 2024, when Microsoft, a known ICE contractor, restricted access to its face recognition API. Now, the site is operational again, “running fully on-device,” McDonald announces on social media.

“After all, this is the sole direct clue the dismayed user gets when things go south,” writes Maya Posch of the Windows blue screen of death and other computer fatal error messages. Tracing the evolution from the AmigaOS guru meditation to Windows 8’s giant sad emoticon over decades, Posch notes how the upcoming black-screened Windows 11 crash strips away technical details entirely—marking a shift from empowering users with information toward leaving them helpless in the event of a malfunction.

R
“The fee I originally received for the Windows 95 chime will now go toward helping the victims of the attacks on Gaza. If a sound can signal real change then let it be this one.”
– Musician Brian Eno, in a call for Microsoft to cut ties with Israel’s Ministry of Defence. Reflecting on his iconic soundmark, he recalls how in the 1990s personal computing represented “a gateway to a promising technological future.” That future, he argues, has been co-opted by military applications, urging musicians, tech workers, and citizens to speak up.
“It turns out 1989’s ‘Rhythm Nation’ harbours the resonant frequency for components within 5,400 RPM hard drives, causing the moving parts of the hard drive to vibrate in arcs that would gradually sweep wider than intended.”
– Journalist Jess Kinghorn, revealing how the bassline in a Janet Jackson song caused laptops to crash in the mid-2000s. “Microsoft wrote some Digital Signal Processing code to filter out the offending frequencies on Windows XP machines,” Kinghorn writes, detailing the resolution of the fluke issue.
“Sometimes, we’d leave Skype on all day and night, not always speaking, just being part of each other’s routines. It became a quiet but constant presence in our relationship.”
– Nicole, describing how Skype kept her connected with her (now) fiancé during the onset of COVID-19. Nicole is just one of dozens of global users who share heartfelt testimonials about the impact Skype had on their lives, in advance of Microsoft shutting down the voice communication platform in May.

Circular shapes, central openings, radiating lines: Radek Sienkiewicz, aka VelvetShark, has an idea why AI company logos resemble buttholes. “Circles represent wholeness, completion, and infinity—concepts that align with AI’s promise. They’re also friendly and non-threatening, qualities companies desperately want to project when selling potentially job-replacing technology.” The visual conformity reveals a race for legitimacy, Sienkiewicz concludes, and ”the fear of standing out.”

“My first games involved hand assembling machine code and turning graph paper characters into hex digits. Software progress has made that work as irrelevant as chariot wheel maintenance.”
– Id Software founder John Carmack, defending (rapid) AI research. Responding to concerns over Microsoft’s AI-generated replica of Quake II—a fully playable tech demo simulating the 1997 Carmack classic—the legendary game developer argues that “building power tools is central to all the progress in computers.” The caveat: “Will there be more or less game developer jobs? That is an open question.”
“If I knew my work on transcription scenarios would help spy on and transcribe phone calls to better target Palestinians, I would not have joined Microsoft and contributed to genocide. I did not sign up to write code that violates human rights.”
– Microsoft employee Ibtihal Aboussad, in a company-wide email. During a protest at a 50th anniversary event, the AI software engineer condemned Microsoft’s contracts with Israel’s Ministry of Defense and urged her colleagues to demand an end to the relationship.
“If chatbots can be persuaded to change their answers by a paragraph of white text, or a secret message written in code, why would we trust them with any task, let alone ones with actual stakes?”
– Tech columnist Kevin Roose, on how easily AI systems can be gamed. Eager to improve his tainted reputation with chatbots after his viral Sydney take-down forced industry-wide safety measures (Meta’s Llama 3: “I hate Kevin Roose!“), the American author and journalist uncovers a number of shockingly simple hacks to steer answers. “Oracles shouldn’t be this easy to manipulate,” he warns.
“RIP Yves Klein, you would have loved the CrowdStrike outage.”
– Architectural historian and writer Alexander Luckmann, finding humour in the unprecedented global failure of computer systems by linking the tsunami of reported ‘blue screens of death’—Window’s fatal error message—to the late French artist’s patented pigment
“Can AI improve climate modelling? Yes, but that doesn’t change the fact that AI energy demands are growing disproportionally to any efficiency gains.”
Hugging Face’s Climate and AI Lead Sasha Luccioni, airing frustrations about AI greenwashing while emissions from Microsoft and Google data centers soar. “AI is a relatively small part of the [climate] solution,” Luccioni tells technology pundit and Tech Won’t Save Us host Paris Marx. “The rest is domain expertise—people who actually know what they’re doing.”
“It’s more than Apple and Microsoft’s market caps combined. It’s more than than any company has raised for anything in the history of capitalism.”
New York Times tech columnist Kevin Roose, contextualizing the reported $5-7 Trillion in funding OpenAI CEO Sam Altman is seeking to boost global GPU production. The staggering amount “is a really good indicator of what people in positions of leadership in the AI industry think that is going to take to get AI to the next level,” says Roose.
“Copyright only works above a certain threshold of importance. That’s something you learn as an artist. Your voice doesn’t matter.”
– Artist and experimental filmmaker Robert Seidel, on how little leverage artists have against data-hungry AI companies compared to major institutions like The New York Times, which sued OpenAI and Microsoft for copyright infringement the day before Seidel’s talk at the 37th Chaos Communication Congress (37c3)
“As U.S. et al. v. Google goes to trial, the echoes of the landmark federal suit against Microsoft, a quarter-century ago, are unmistakable.”
– Tech journalist Steve Lohr, reminiscing the last major American antitrust trial (1998). Once again “a tech giant is accused of using its overwhelming market power to unfairly cut competitors off from potential customers,” Lohr writes, noting Google is not quite as audacious though (a Microsoft exec famously planned to “cut off Netscape’s air supply”).

Deep demake or meta media archaeology? Thanks to programmer WebFritzi, retro gaming fans can now enjoy Windows 95 classics Solitaire, Freecell, and Minesweeper on a Commodore 64—iconic Windows 95 desktop interface and mouse support included. Recreating an authentic 1995 PC experience on an 8-bit platform from a decade prior required some assembly language wizardry. “How are the icons created? Can you make a user interface like this? I just couldn’t believe what I was seeing,” stunned Commodore fans wrote online.

To dive deeper into Stream, please or become a .

Daily discoveries at the nexus of art, science, technology, and culture: Get full access by becoming a HOLO Supporter!
  • Perspective: research, long-form analysis, and critical commentary
  • Encounters: in-depth artist profiles and studio visits of pioneers and key innovators
  • Stream: a timeline and news archive with 3,100+ entries and counting
  • Edition: HOLO’s annual collector’s edition that captures the calendar year in print
.
$40 USD