Exhibitions, Research, Criticism, Commentary

A chronology of 3,585 references across art, science, technology, and culture

Building on cyberethnographer Ruby Justice Thélot’s ARTnews meditation on AI and digital folk art creation, critic Louis Bury lists ten examples—art, books, essays—that speak to this tension in 2025. Bury’s picks include Dean Kissick’s dissection of “The Vulgar Image,” Agent 5.5’s QAnon-esque John Pork TikTok lore, artist Maya Man’s “funhouse vision of TikTok vernacular’s over-the-top banality” for the Whitney, and Nadia Asparouhova’s cult hit book Antimemetics (2025).

“I think everyone will miss the socializing part. But it’s also a relief to not have to do that on a platform designed to lure you in and waste your time, no one is going to miss scrolling.”
– Australian teenager Emma Williams, about the country’s imminent world-first social media ban for under-16s. Williams was one of five teens interviewed about their feelings as the ban approaches—responses ranged from indifference to frustration, though most noted they’d simply shift from Instagram and TikTok to messaging apps unaffected by the legislation.
“As a matter of fact, a lot of people are already trying to take over the mantle of ‘the person who debates college freshman’ because they see that as a very successful vehicle to deliver a right-wing message to a much broader audience on the internet.”
– Political streamer Hasan Piker, noting that “slam dunk [TikTok] compilations” of right-wing pundits humiliating college students will not end with Charlie Kirk. Speaking of his slain opponent, Piker warns of the coming storm of “indecipherable politics around meme culture.”

“Ambient Propaganda” at Utrecht’s IMPAKT Centre for Media Culture examines the shift from top-down to ambient influence, a new regime “where ideology is subconsciously incorporated into everyday digital culture.” From TikTok trends to political fandoms, the featured works by Noura Tafeche, Lesia Vasylchenko, Total Refusal, Paolo Cirio, Fantastic Little Splash and others highlight “how the boundaries between self-expression, performance, and ideological reproduction have blurred.”

“We’re all becoming NPCs, nudged by recommendation engines, not through Orwellian control but by the seduction of ease and feedback.”
– Internet artists Eva & Franco Mattes, on the algorithmic pressures that drive the attention economy. Case in point: But I Love Human (2024), a 12-minute video collage of NPC streamers—performers who mimic videogame non-player characters (NPCs) in live broadcasts, often to earn money—that the duo premiered at this year’s Vienna Digital Cultures. “Life becomes performance staged for algorithms, we sculpt for Instagram, we dance for TikTok.”
“Yayoi Kusama inaugurated a new era of art specifically catering to smartphone engagement. The conceptual artist James Turrell soon had a crossover moment when Drake visited his exhibition and later used it as the inspiration for the ‘Hotline Bling’ music video.”
– T Magazine Features Director M.H. Miller, tracing the lineage of art that goes viral on social media—from Tumblr to TikTok. [quote edited]
B
“The voice of novel technological communication has been, almost from the beginning, a female voice, which is to say the voice of a helper, a perfect helper, pleasant, unflappable, immune to insults, come-ons and bossiness.”
– Journalist Susan Dominus, underscoring the prominence of female voices in AI assistants and apps—from Siri and Alexa to Jessie, a text-to-speech model used widely on TikTok.

Is Ben Grosser scrolling TikTok right now? Find out via Stuck in the Scroll (2024), a new website in which the American artist invites us to monitor his social media addiction. “Think of it as a last-ditch effort, a sort of public confessional as therapeutic tool aimed at defusing the intense compulsion I feel every day to endlessly scroll the world’s most popular video app,” Grosser writes. In going public, he aims to probe the designed effects of platform interfaces and, ultimately, “to break free from the engagement loop.”

“The logic is that TikTok is the beating heart of a social-media industrial complex that mines our data and uses them to manipulate our behavior, and, as such, it is very bad for an authoritarian country to have access to these tools.”
– Tech columnist Charlie Warzel, encapsulating the U.S. bill demanding that ByteDance, TikTok’s parent company, sell its app or be banned in America. Skeptical that ‘ties to China’ is the real problem, Warzel notes “if the government believes this is true, should anyone have access to these tools?”

“The future’s gonna be weirder than anyone can imagine,” Turkish AI artist Memo Akten writes about the effect TikTok’s newly released Teenage Filter has on people. “It makes you look young,” he demonstrates in an uncanny reaction video, “and now TikTok is full of middle-aged folks trying come to terms with this, trying to understand where their life went.” Facing your younger self can be “quite emotional,” says Akten and provides dozens of examples in a (now viral) Twitter thread.

“If you look at TikTok your body is literally animated by the algorithm—it tells you how to move yourself—and you end up dancing for this abstract formulation of capital and algorithmic recommendation.”
– Online subculture researcher Joshua Citarella, describing the diminishing agency of internet content creators. In his assessment, “people were able to make targeted critical interventions … shape it [media] with intent,” a decade ago—now users “are instrumentalized by the algorithim itself.”
“It takes a filter designed for people of colour to make us realize the extent to which most filters aren’t.”
– Writer Leo Kim, exploring TikTok filters not made for white faces. “Tools of representation are neither objective nor inevitable,” writes Kim. “Like all popular technologies, their development is motivated by a variety of economic interests and swayed by assumptions and bias.”
To dive deeper into Stream, please or become a .

Daily discoveries at the nexus of art, science, technology, and culture: Get full access by becoming a HOLO Supporter!
  • Perspective: research, long-form analysis, and critical commentary
  • Encounters: in-depth artist profiles and studio visits of pioneers and key innovators
  • Stream: a timeline and news archive with 3,100+ entries and counting
  • Edition: HOLO’s annual collector’s edition that captures the calendar year in print
.