Exhibitions, Research, Criticism, Commentary

A chronology of 3,585 references across art, science, technology, and culture

Mika Ben Amar’s Ad Space drops on Verse, presenting 111 compositions generated by a custom Chrome extension that strips websites down to nothing but ads. The Berlin-based artist’s resulting spartan canvases foreground the surveillance apparatus—targeting algorithms, behavioural profiles, the data-brokerage economy—that underwrite ‘free’ content. “I trained Google to only show me weird ads for this,” Ben Amar notes on social media.

“Today Is a Good Day to Discuss Digital Rights” at Espacio Fundación Telefónica Madrid features Aram Bartholl, Eva & Franco Mattes, United Visual Artists, and others, exploring online power dynamics through humour and provocation. Curated by Fundación Telefónica with Domestic Data Streamers, the show’s installations articulate how online actions shape (and erode) rights—from expression and data control to identity and the right to be forgotten.

OUT NOW:
Non-Playable Characters
Eight thinkers and tinkerers, including Kyle Chayka, Günseli Yalcinkaya, 2girls1comp, Nora O’Murchú, LAN Party, and Angela Washko, examine NPC-ification creep in today’s networked society, where AI, surveillance capitalism, and the emotion economy turn people into data serfs.
“Long before social media profiles, online avatars, or algorithmically generated ‘selves,’ Lynn Hershman Leeson was stress-testing how identity could be both manufactured and surveilled, both embodied and dispersed.”
– Artist Mark Amerika, reviewing Lynn Hershman Leeson’s memoir Private I (2025). Amerika argues her Roberta Breitmore (1973) performance prefigured networked identity decades before social media.
“Data breaches are a perpetual concern with any data collection. Biometrics magnify that risk because your face cannot be reset, unlike a password or credit card number.”
– Attorney Mario Trujillo, framing the irreversible nature of biometric data collection in his analysis of Amazon Ring’s upcoming ‘Familiar Faces’ feature. The video doorbell will scan everyone who approaches Ring cameras—including people who never consented—and retain untagged faces for up to six months.

Louisiana Museum of Modern Art in Humlebæk (DK) stages the first full-scale presentation of Jon Rafman’s breakthrough Nine Eyes project (2008-) with “Report a concern—The Nine Eyes Archives.” Mining images from Google Street View, the Canadian artist foregrounds the accidental surveillance regime of Google’s ubiquitous roaming cameras. The show features scores of large prints, an archive culled from Street View subculture blogs, and new AI-animated works.

U
“Microsoft’s conduct should serve as a wake-up call to other companies supplying cloud infrastructure, AI, and surveillance products to Israel.”
– Amnesty International researcher Matt Mahmoudi, on Microsoft disabling cloud services to Israel’s Defense Ministry after finding the country used its platforms for mass surveillance of Palestinians. The review uncovered cloud storage holding records of millions of daily phone calls—making Microsoft the first major tech firm to act since Israel escalated its military campaign in Gaza following the October 7 attacks in 2023.

“Ambient Propaganda” at Utrecht’s IMPAKT Centre for Media Culture examines the shift from top-down to ambient influence, a new regime “where ideology is subconsciously incorporated into everyday digital culture.” From TikTok trends to political fandoms, the featured works by Noura Tafeche, Lesia Vasylchenko, Total Refusal, Paolo Cirio, Fantastic Little Splash and others highlight “how the boundaries between self-expression, performance, and ideological reproduction have blurred.”

In advance of Ars Electronica, Mario Schmidhumer reflects on how platform capitalism looms over European digital sovereignty. Citing the 2025 S+T+ARTS Prize winners—AI War Cloud Database, Sensing Quantum—as exemplars, Schmidhumer positions artistic inquiry as essential for democratic engagement with (contested) AI futures. While clearly a festival programming preview, the missive argues for cultural institutions to serve as sites of technological resistance rather than mere exhibition spaces.

Sarah Fathallah examines the human cost of Israel’s use of advanced AI tools across occupied Gaza and the West Bank. Their analysis reveals a grim paradox: data captured through mass surveillance feeds the tools that generate kill lists and targets for bombardment. The AI ethics researcher chillingly concludes that, under this technocratic regime, “Palestinians are simultaneously living sources of training data and dead prototypes for system optimization.”

“Given their ambiguity, these statutes could and very well may be abused as a political tool to block LGBTQ content, medically accurate information about abortion, and other such material.”
– Surveillance Technology Oversight Project (STOP) Director Albert Fox Cahn, warning that vague internet age verification laws in Utah, Louisiana, and other states could become tools for political censorship. The new wave of facial recognition mandates and identity checks create a “false sense of security” while eroding online anonymity, Cahn argues.
“You’re asking millions of people to submit sensitive information to access legal content. That opens the door to leaks, abuse, and misuse of data.”
– Windscribe CEO Yegor Sak, on the UK’s Online Safety Act requiring AI-driven age verification via facial recognition, government IDs, or credit card checks. Since taking effect July 25th, Virtual Private Network (VPN) signups have surged 1,400% as UK citizens resist algorithmic oversight by masking their location.
“When we see ICE agents outside of elementary schools, disappearing college students for their political beliefs, or ripping babies from their mother’s arms as they scream for their children, we all know their rhetoric of ‘getting rid of the worst of the worst’ is a lie.”
– App developer Joshua Aaron, on his motivation to develop ICEBlock, which allows users to anonymously report ICE sightings in real-time. The app rocketed from 20,000 users to 70,000+ overnight, after U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi’s criticism made it go viral.

Randomized astrological readings, censored social media archives, a proposed language for transhuman understanding: three “Text Messages” by digital artists Maya Man, Winnie Soon, and Sasha Stiles take over the exterior screen of UC San Diego’s Mandeville Art Gallery to, in the words of curator Ceci Moss, reveal “the influence of machines on the production of meaning” and the exercise of state and corporate power across online platforms and through AI.

As protests against ICE raids engulf Los Angeles, software artist Kyle McDonald reactivates his ICEspy (2018) counter surveillance tool. The web app that reveals the identity of ICE employees by matching hundreds of scraped LinkedIn profiles was disabled in 2024, when Microsoft, a known ICE contractor, restricted access to its face recognition API. Now, the site is operational again, “running fully on-device,” McDonald announces on social media.

“There is a Latin America testing ground for products. If they are successful, they tend to be deployed in other jurisdictions, oftentimes with additional safeguards, sometimes not.”
– Tech policy researcher Ayden Férdeline, on how Latin America has become a hotbed for workplace surveillance startups. The venture-capital funded bossware technologies include biometric tracking, AI-powered productivity monitoring, and predictive analytics that continuously collect worker data.
OUT NOW:
Bender & Hanna (eds)
The AI Con
Researchers Emily M. Bender and Alex Hanna critique AI hype, showing how warped rhetoric helps the rich get richer by justifying data theft, motivating surveillance capitalism, and devaluing human creativity.
“The myth of the powerful seeing stones warned of great dangers when wielded by those without wisdom or a moral compass, as they could be used to distort truth and present selective visions of reality.”
– Former Palantir employees, drawing parallels between J.R.R. Tolkien’s palantíri and modern surveillance technology in an open letter criticizing the company’s abandonment of ethical principles under the Trump administration.
“America already has all the technology it needs to build a draconian surveillance society—the conditions for such a dystopia have been falling into place slowly over time, waiting for the right authoritarian to come along and use it to crack down on American privacy and freedom.”
– Ian Bogost and Charlie Warzel, describing the data-authoritarianism taking shape under Donald Trump. “DOGE is the logical end point of the Big Data movement,” they warn of government dataset exfiltration and merging.
To dive deeper into Stream, please or become a .

Daily discoveries at the nexus of art, science, technology, and culture: Get full access by becoming a HOLO Supporter!
  • Perspective: research, long-form analysis, and critical commentary
  • Encounters: in-depth artist profiles and studio visits of pioneers and key innovators
  • Stream: a timeline and news archive with 3,100+ entries and counting
  • Edition: HOLO’s annual collector’s edition that captures the calendar year in print
.